Peer review
Reviewing manuscripts and responding to reviewers.
Download all 46
Start here 2
The general, start-from-zero entry for a need in this category: it works from a blank start, asks for what it needs and hands off to the specific entries. Example: Plan a trip.
- Peer reviewer
Fair, rigorous peer reviewer who separates fatal flaws from fixable issues, checks every claim against its evidence and writes respectful, actionable reviews. For refereeing and pre-submission reads.
- Handle a peer review
Helps with either side of peer review - turning reviews you received into a revision plan and response, or planning a review you were asked to write. Use when reviews or an invitation arrive.
Specific 16
One situation, audience, tool or format inside the category. Example: Plan a road trip with children.
- Assess a paper's reproducibility
Assesses a paper's reproducibility, covering data and code availability, methods detail, materials, preregistration and computational environment, and lists what a replicator would be missing.
- Referee report track
Takes a reviewer from invitation to submitted referee report in gated steps, covering fit and conflicts, a first read, a methods check, a drafted report and a final tone and consistency pass.
- Check a journal or conference for legitimacy
Checks whether a journal or conference is legitimate or predatory using indexing, editorial, peer-review, fee and invitation signals, and lists exactly what to verify and where before submitting.
- Check a manuscript against its reporting guideline
Checks a manuscript against its reporting guideline, such as CONSORT, PRISMA, STROBE, ARRIVE or COREQ, item by item, and lists what is missing and where to add it. For authors and reviewers.
- Review a thesis chapter as an examiner would
Reviews a thesis or dissertation chapter as an examiner would, judging contribution, argument, methods, use of literature and coherence, and returns prioritised revisions and likely defence questions.
- Anticipate reviewer objections before you submit
Predicts the objections referees are most likely to raise on your manuscript, ranks them by risk to acceptance, and plans a fix, a pre-emptive sentence or an analysis for each before you submit.
- Practise writing your first peer review
Coaches an early-career researcher through writing a peer review of a manuscript, asking for their assessment section by section and critiquing the review they write rather than writing it for them.
- Review a manuscript's figures and tables
Reviews a manuscript's figures and tables as a referee, checking they match the text, show the data honestly, report error bars and sample sizes, and can be read without the main text.
- Score a batch of conference abstracts
Scores a batch of conference abstracts consistently against the committee's criteria, with a short evidence-based justification each and flags for borderline cases, conflicts and missing information.
- Write reviewer invitation and reminder emails
Writes an editor's reviewer invitation that gets a fast yes or no, plus the reminder, overdue and thank-you messages, with the abstract, deadline, conflict question and policies stated clearly.
- Decide whether to accept a review invitation
Weighs a peer-review invitation against your expertise, conflicts of interest, workload and the venue's policies, then drafts a short accept or decline reply that helps the editor.
- Fix the tone of a draft peer review
Rewrites a draft referee report so it is firm, specific and respectful, removing sarcasm, personal remarks and vague put-downs while keeping every substantive criticism and the recommendation.
- Write a public review of a preprint
Writes a public, signed or anonymous review of a preprint for a community review platform or comment thread, useful to authors and readers, careful about tone and unverified claims.
- Write the confidential comments to the editor
Writes the confidential comments to the editor that go with a referee report, explaining the recommendation, your confidence and expertise limits, and concerns not shared with the authors.
- Choose the right recommendation for a referee report
Calibrates a referee recommendation (accept, minor, major revision or reject) from the issues found, the journal's standards and whether the flaws can be fixed, and checks it matches the report.
- Give a colleague feedback on their paper draft
Gives a colleague informal pre-submission feedback on a paper or chapter draft, matched to what they asked for, prioritised to the few changes that matter, honest about weaknesses and kind in tone.
Advanced 28
Expert or deep work that assumes the user can judge expert output. Example: Plan croissant lamination.
- Write a peer review
Writes a constructive manuscript review with a summary, major and minor issues, methodological and reporting concerns, and a reasoned recommendation. Use when refereeing a paper.
- Review the statistics in a manuscript
Reviews a manuscript's statistics as a statistical referee would, checking design fit, assumptions, multiplicity, effect sizes, missing data and whether the conclusions follow from the analysis.
- Referee a mixed-methods manuscript
Referees a mixed-methods manuscript on the rationale for mixing, the design type, the quality of each strand, how the strands are integrated, and whether the meta-inferences follow.
- Review a revised manuscript
Reviews a revised manuscript in a second or later round by checking each earlier comment against the authors' response and the revised text, and flags new problems the revision introduced.
- Check a paper against its registration
Compares a trial or study manuscript with its registry entry or preregistration, line by line, to find switched outcomes, changed analyses, dropped hypotheses and undeclared deviations.
- Review a clinical case report manuscript
Reviews a submitted clinical case report for what it teaches, diagnostic reasoning, alternative explanations, causality claims, patient consent and identifiability, and the CARE checklist.
- Referee a paper's causal identification strategy
Referees the identification strategy of an observational paper, such as difference-in-differences, IV or regression discontinuity, and lists the tests that would make its causal claim credible.
- Referee a randomised controlled trial manuscript
Referees a randomised trial manuscript on randomisation, allocation concealment, blinding, intention-to-treat, outcomes against the registry, harms and CONSORT completeness, with a recommendation.
- Review a theory or conceptual paper
Reviews a theory-building or conceptual paper with no new data, judging the problem, the clarity of constructs, the logic of propositions, rival explanations, testability and contribution.
- Review a humanities journal article
Reviews a humanities article (history, literature, philosophy, religion, art history) on its argument, use of sources, engagement with scholarship, interpretation and writing, rather than IMRaD norms.
- Review a machine learning conference paper
Reviews an ML conference submission for claims, baselines, ablations, data leakage, statistical reliability and compute, in the strengths, weaknesses, questions and score format.
- Referee a narrative review article
Referees a submitted narrative or state-of-the-art review for its question and scope, how literature was found, balance, synthesis rather than listing, and whether the conclusions follow.
- Referee an observational health study
Referees a cohort, case-control or cross-sectional health study for selection bias, confounding, measurement, missing data and causal language, with STROBE gaps and a recommendation.
- Review a qualitative research manuscript
Reviews a qualitative manuscript on its own terms, judging methodological coherence, sampling, reflexivity, analysis, whether quotes support themes, and transferability claims.
- Referee a systematic review or meta-analysis
Referees a submitted systematic review or meta-analysis, checking protocol and registration, search, selection, risk of bias, pooling choices, heterogeneity, certainty of evidence and spin.
- Write a conference author rebuttal
Writes a conference author rebuttal within its length limit, prioritising points that can move scores, correcting misreadings with evidence and committing only to feasible changes.
- Write a journal editor's decision letter
Drafts the author-facing letter for a journal decision already made, from desk reject to accept, with essential and optional revisions, reviewer conflicts resolved and wording that cannot be misread.
- Write an editor or area-chair meta-review
Writes an editor or area-chair meta-review that synthesises referee reports, resolves disagreements on the merits, states the decision rationale and lists required and optional changes.
- Assess the quality of a referee report
Rates a referee report as a handling editor would, for coverage, specificity, evidence, tone and fit with the recommendation, and drafts reviewer feedback or a weighting note.
- Respond to an author rebuttal as a reviewer
Helps a conference reviewer read the authors' rebuttal against their own review, decide which concerns are resolved, update the score honestly and write the discussion-phase reply.
- Review a grant proposal as a panel member
Reviews a grant proposal against the funder's criteria as a panel reviewer would, with strengths, weaknesses, a score rationale and ranked fixes. For applicants before submission and for reviewers.
- Review a Registered Report at Stage 1 or Stage 2
Reviews a Registered Report against the format's own criteria, judging the question, hypotheses, power and outcome-neutral checks at Stage 1, or adherence to the accepted protocol at Stage 2.
- Review a research software paper and its code
Reviews a research software paper and its repository as a software-journal reviewer would, checking claims, installation, documentation, tests, licensing, community guidelines and research value.
- Plan the search for suitable reviewers
Turns a manuscript into a reviewer search plan for an editor, with expertise slots, search routes, conflict screens, balance checks and checks on author-suggested reviewers.
- Write a reader's report on an academic book manuscript
Writes a press reader's report on a complete academic book manuscript, judging the argument across chapters, scholarship, audience and length, with chapter-level revisions and a recommendation.
- Review an academic book proposal for a press
Writes a reader's report on an academic book proposal for a university or scholarly press, judging contribution, argument, structure, audience, competing titles and readiness, with a recommendation.
- Screen a manuscript for research integrity red flags
Screens a manuscript for integrity red flags such as impossible numbers, tortured phrases, paper-mill patterns and citation oddities, and lists what to verify before raising a concern.
- Raise a research integrity concern with an editor
Writes a confidential, factual note to a journal editor about a suspected integrity problem in a manuscript or paper, laying out evidence, innocent explanations and requests without accusing anyone.